overnyt
Broker Control Maturity Model

Five levels of operational control.

Where does your firm sit today, from spreadsheets to autonomous, evidenced control? Use the model to benchmark your operations and see what the next level requires.

5 levels9 questions2 minutes

The model

Most brokers are at level 1 or 2. Regulators increasingly expect level 4.

Level 1

Manual

Spreadsheets

Reconciliations built by hand in spreadsheets each morning. Breaks tracked in email. Evidence rebuilt when the auditor asks.

Level 2

Assisted

Scripts and macros

Some matching automated with scripts or macros. Still person-dependent; exceptions and approvals live outside the system.

Level 3

Tooled

Reconciliation tool

A reconciliation tool flags differences. People investigate and fix them elsewhere; approvals and evidence are partly recorded.

Level 4

Controlled

Daily control layer

Reconciliation performed on versioned rules, every fix approved by a named person, evidence recorded and replayable, controls attested daily.

Level 5

Autonomous

Agent-run, human-signed

AI agents explain and resolve low-risk breaks within limits the control owner set; people review exceptions and sign off. The audit pack is a download.

Self-assessment

Score your firm.

Answer for your most important daily reconciliation. Nothing is stored or sent.

  1. 1.Are your daily reconciliations produced without anyone building a spreadsheet?

  2. 2.Is every match made on written, versioned rules that someone approved?

  3. 3.Is every break explained with the source records that disagree?

  4. 4.Does a different, named person approve each fix before it is posted?

  5. 5.Can you replay any past day's reconciliation and get exactly the same result?

  6. 6.Are inputs and decisions kept in a record that cannot be edited afterwards?

  7. 7.Are client-money or safeguarding checks attested by a named owner every day?

  8. 8.Could you hand an auditor the evidence for any date range within an hour?

  9. 9.Do automated agents explain or resolve routine breaks within approved limits?

Dawn

See what your night produced.

Open the morning report and make a few decisions yourself. Or send us one night of source files and we will run your reconciliation in front of you.

skhan@03vc.com